After Pop (Danny Aiello) learns that he is dying, his lat request is for one of his sons, Tom or Jeff (T.R. Knight), to get married and have a son to carry on the family name. But when Tom dies trying, it's up to Jeff - who's in the seminary studying to become a priest! When Pop asks Jeff "who's more important, your father or someone you've never met before?", he leaves the seminary and sets off on his new calling... to fulfill Pop's last request.